Walk into any vintage shop and you'll find a rack of old band tees. Some are tour shirts from 1987. Some were printed in a garage last year on a blank from 1987. Some are full reproductions on brand new Gildan. And honestly? The distinctions matter less than you'd think.
This is a quick guide to understanding what you're looking at when you shop vintage tees — and how we think about the collection at Pemulis.
The Spectrum
True Vintage
Original shirt, original print, original era. A Metallica tee from the 1991 tour, sold at the show, worn ever since. These are the grails — and they're priced accordingly.
Vintage Bootlegs
Unauthorized graphics printed during the original era. Parking lot merch. Flea market specials. The band never saw a dime, and that's part of the point. Often more interesting than the official stuff.
Overprints
Vintage blank, new print. Someone finds deadstock Hanes Beefy-Ts from 1994, prints a new graphic on them. The shirt is real vintage — the weight, the softness, the tag — but the design is contemporary. Best of both worlds.
Reproductions
New blank, vintage-style print. What you find at Urban Outfitters or Target. Nothing wrong with it, but it's not what we carry.
The Bootleg Tradition
Bootleg tees aren't counterfeits. They're folk art. Unauthorized tributes made by fans, for fans, outside the official merch machine. The graphics are often weirder, bolder, and more creative than anything a label would approve.
Before the internet made everything licensable, bootleggers were the ones keeping obscure bands and cult movies alive on cotton. Someone in a screen printing shop decided the world needed a Natural Born Killers tee with a graphic the studio would never sanction. They were right.
This is culture that exists because people made it exist — not because a marketing team approved it.
How We Source
Our vintage tee collection comes from all over:
- Thrift shops — The classic dig. Most of it is garbage. Occasionally, gold.
- Estate sales — Where the real archives live. Someone's older brother had taste in 1993.
- Overprint artists — We work with printers who specialize in vintage blanks and original graphics.
- In-house — Some designs we create ourselves (more on that below).
Not every piece comes with a certificate of authenticity. We describe what we know in each listing — but this isn't StockX. If you're buying vintage tees expecting archival documentation, you're in the wrong hobby. You're buying because the graphic is hard, the shirt is soft, and it fits the way new blanks never will.
Pemulis Originals
We design our own graphics in the bootleg tradition — unauthorized tributes, remixed references, and original weirdness. Some are printed on vintage blanks. Some aren't. All of them continue the tradition of making the shirt you couldn't find at the merch table.
If bootleggers are folk artists, we're just adding to the canon.
Shop the Collection
We don't organize by "authentic" vs "bootleg" — we organize by what's on the shirt:
One-of-one vintage pieces are gone when they're gone. Pemulis Originals are available in multiple sizes while stock lasts.